| Date | Player | Home Runs | |
| 05-12-1951 | Barry Hopkins | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 5 RBI versus San Francisco while playing for Cincinnati | |
| 08-10-1951 | Mike Nadler | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 4 RBI versus Detroit while playing for Los Angeles | |
| 08-16-1951 | Pedro Ortíz | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 5, 3 RBI versus San Francisco while playing for Chicago | |
| 09-14-1951 | Fernando Vallés | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 3, 6 RBI versus Chicago while playing for St. Louis | |
| 09-19-1952 | Bubba Washington | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 5, 5 RBI versus Pittsburgh while playing for Los Angeles | |
| 05-01-1953 | Paul Young | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 4 RBI versus Boston while playing for Baltimore | |
| 06-07-1953 | José Vera | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 4, 4 RBI versus Los Angeles while playing for San Francisco | |
| 06-26-1953 | Jeremy Jones | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 6 RBI versus San Francisco while playing for Pittsburgh | |
| 07-26-1953 | Willie Johnston | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 7 RBI versus New York while playing for Boston | |
| 09-04-1953 | Tzu-hsia Ji | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 4, 4 RBI versus Cleveland while playing for Washington | |
| 06-20-1954 | Ángel Moya | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 5, 7 RBI versus Los Angeles while playing for Chicago | |
| 08-07-1955 | Ricardo León | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 6, 4 RBI versus Atlanta while playing for Chicago | |
| 09-07-1955 | Gil Hanson | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 6 RBI versus Boston while playing for New York | |
| 04-19-1956 | Alfredo Alvarado | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 5, 5 RBI versus Detroit while playing for New York | |
| 05-26-1956 | Ángel Moya | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 5, 4 RBI versus Cleveland while playing for Chicago | |
| 09-26-1956 | Tim Clayton | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 8 RBI versus Los Angeles while playing for Chicago | |
| 05-03-1957 | Ángel Moya | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 4 RBI versus Detroit while playing for Chicago | |
| 04-21-1958 | Bruno Paul | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 3, 8 RBI versus Chicago while playing for Los Angeles | |
| 08-03-1958 | Ben Anderson | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 3, 3 RBI versus Boston while playing for Cincinnati | |
| 08-15-1959 | Chandler Caldwell | 3 Home Runs, 4 for 5, 6 RBI versus Atlanta while playing for St. Louis | |
| 09-17-1959 | Barry Baldwin | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 4 RBI versus Los Angeles while playing for Washington | |
| 06-16-1961 | José Soriano | 3 Home Runs, 3 for 4, 5 RBI versus New York while playing for Los Angeles | |
